A wealthy defense attorney is killed at her son’s wedding but Nick’s car, containing all the collected evidence is stolen and the case is compromised. After discovering new evidence, the team suspects that someone from the wedding party may be responsible for the murder.

Golfer David Ogron tries to set the world record for most golf balls shot in 30 minutes (and succeeds); during "Who Asked For It?", a faux audience member unwittingly reveals George Clarke's lust for Dave; the top three finishers in the Piedmont Bird-Calling Competition demonstrate their abilities; Emmylou Harris and Mark Knopfler perform "This Is Us."

John has realized where the demon will strike next and the Winchesters head there to stop the next killing. But Meg begins killing John's friends and demands the Colt or she'll keep going until everyone John knows is dead.

Stephen Colbert welcomes the editor of "The Weekly Standard", Bill Kristol!

Monologue/Opening: Graig rips on the new Elton John produced musical "Lestat" and notes the horrible reviews it has recieved from the critics. Later, Graig as "Larry King" interviews "President George W. Bush." Guests: ANDY GARCIA talks about his new movie "Lost in the City." KRISTIN CHENOWETH stops by to chat about her new movie "RV." Later, hip-hop sensation DEM FRANCHIZE BOYZ perform.

Dwight plays the role of Volunteer Sheriff after finding half a joint in the Dunder Mifflin parking lot leading to an investigation. Pam gives Jim a play challenge where he must be silent until he gives Pam a can of Coke.