After stumbling upon a suspicious murder in Blue Valley, the JSA begin looking at potential suspects. A tense run-in with The Shade makes Courtney and Pat realize that Sylvester’s old ways could land them in hot water. Finally, Barbara steps in to help Paula, whose attempt at fitting in has not gone so well.
Jimmy gives two audience members a made-up song title and an hour to come up with a song to perform on the show, then catches up with Susan Sarandon and Julio Torres before welcoming musical guest FLETCHER.