November, 1970. The challenges of midwifery hit close to home when a mother-and-baby home is evacuated. Nancy’s wedding plans take a surprising turn, and Sister Catherine takes her first vows.

Peter runs into Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh at a brewery tour, and the two drink the night into oblivion. When Peter wakes up, he realizes their lives have swapped, and he joins the Supreme Court as Brett Kavanaugh, and Brett returns to Quahog as Peter.